Mandate

Vinge advised SAS in alleged discrimination claim

March 26, 2013

Vinge has advised SAS in its successful defence in proceedings at Stockholm District Court where Swedish SAS pilots had pursued an action in damages against SAS for alleged breaches of EU law.

The 33 SAS pilots were previously employed by Linjeflyg and commenced proceedings against SAS for alleged breaches of EU law in connection with their employment by SAS following the winding up of Linjeflyg in 1992. In brief, the claimants alleged that SAS had acted unlawfully by failing to permit them to include the period of service with their previous employer and as a consequence thereof had discriminated against them due to their Swedish nationality and thereby preventing them from exercising their freedom of movement under EU law.

The Court dismissed the claimant’s claims in a judgment delivered on 22 March this year. In its judgment, the Court states that EU law is not applicable to the pilots’ employment agreements since the circumstances pertained to purely internal, Swedish circumstances. The Court also notes that even if EU law had been applicable, the pilots’ claims could not succeed. The terms of employment did not entail that the pilots were discriminated against on the ground of their nationality or that they were prevented from exercising their right of free movement. Rather, the pilots had in fact received more favourable treatment compared to other newly-employed SAS pilots. In addition, the terms of employment were not contrary to generally accepted practice on the labour market or otherwise incompatible with Swedish labour law.  

The pilots now have three weeks in which to appeal the District Court’s judgment to the Swedish Labour Court. The Labour Court must also grant permission to appeal.

Vinge’s team consisted of Fredrik Gustafsson, Martin Johansson and Björn Lindskog.

New partners and counsel appointed at Vinge’s Malmö and Stockholm offices

Advokat Daniel Daun and advokat Victor Ericsson at Vinge’s Malmö and Stockholm offices respectively have been appointed as new partners as of 1 January 2023. Jacob Jeanrond, Caroline Krassén, Henrik Schön, Maria Dahlin Kolvik, Sara Strandberg and Linn Adelwald have been elected as counsel at Vinge’s Stockholm office.
June 30, 2022

COP26 - a step in the right direction to achieve the Paris Agreement goals

On 13 November 2021, the two-week international climate summit COP26, held in Glasgow, UK, was concluded after leaders from over 190 countries agreed on a new deal, the so-called Climate Pact in Glasgow. The aim of COP26 was for leaders from around the world to agree on how to step up global action to tackle the climate crisis. The agreement, which will set the global average temperature increase at between 1.8 and 2.4 degrees Celsius, is a step towards achieving the Paris Agreement's (COP21) more ambitious target of a maximum increase of 1.5 degrees.
June 23, 2022

The EU Court of Justice dismisses Belgium’s request in Opinion 1/20, but points out that the dispute settlement mechanism of ECT is not applicable to ‘intra-EU disputes’

The Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) is under renegotiation. Its Article 26, which provides a dispute settlement mechanism, has however not been announced as being subject to such renegotiations. On 2 December 2020, Belgium submitted a request to the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) for an opinion on whether the dispute settlement mechanism of the draft ECT, assuming it remains unchanged, could be interpreted as allowing its application intra-European Union, i.e. between an EU Member State and an investor who is a national of another Member State, and whether this would be compatible with the EU Treaties, in particular Article 19 TEU on the role of the CJEU and Article 344 TFEU on the autonomy of EU law.
June 17, 2022